Apple vs. Samsung: 27 Law Professors Support Samsung in Lawsuit between Apple and Samsung | BusinessKorea

Tuesday, August 04, 2015

2 June 2014 - 5:16pm

27 law professors in the U.S. announced that they support Samsung in the first patent infringement lawsuit between Apple and Samsung.

According to German-based blog FOSS Patents on May 31 (local time), a group of 27 law professors led by Stanford’s Mark Lemley declared that they support Samsung related to design patent issues in the first California Apple vs. Samsung litigation through an amicus curiae brief submitted to the Federal Circuit. 

Three of the 27 signatories of that amicus brief — Professors Cotter, Ghosh and Strandburg — supported Apple last year connected with standard-essential patent issues in the same lawsuit. A law professor who formerly studied Art & Design was included in the group. 

The amicus brief states that the idea of taking back an infringer’s entire profit for design patent infringement goes back to the 19th century. Furthermore, the law professors argued that U.S. lawmakers in 1887 had products such as carpets in mind, not smartphones. 

There are a variety of functions and design patents related to the iPhone, including casing-related, icon-related, and screen layout-related patents.

If the Federal Circuit accepts professors’ opinions, the total amount that Samsung has to compensate in the first case will be much lowered. 

In November of last year, the United States District Court for the Northern District of California issued a ruling against Samsung in the first patent lawsuit, saying that Samsung infringed on Apple’s design patents, and that the Korean tech giant must pay Apple damages worth US$930 million (1 trillion won).


More Like This

Apple vs. Samsung
Wednesday, 30 July 2014
According to German patent blog FOSS Patents on July 28 (local time), Apple submitted a document to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which says that it will drop a cross-...
Friends of the Court
Thursday, 23 July 2015
Facebook and Google sided with Samsung Electronics when the Korean company argued that indemnities resulting from its violation of Apple's patents were excessive. According to Forbes on July 21,...
No Innovation
Friday, 13 December 2013
Samsung Electronics lost the second round of its lawsuit over patent disputes with Apple on its home turf. In the first round battle focusing on “standard patents” in August last year, the local...
Samsung-Apple Patent War
Wednesday, 20 November 2013
In the US lawsuit filed by Apple against Samsung Electronics, the court replied, “It is possible to restrict sales of Samsung Electronics’ products due to utility patent issues.” As the previous...
Apple vs. Samsung
Thursday, 07 August 2014
On August 6, Samsung Electronics and Apple reportedly reached an agreement to withdraw their patent lawsuits occurring outside the U.S. As a result, much attention is being paid to whether their...
Copycat Denial
Monday, 08 December 2014
Samsung Electronics is moving to erase its record, requesting to quash the first trial decision of the first lawsuit between Samsung and Apple back in May. On Dec. 5 the Korean IT giant argued, “...

Copyright 2013 BusinessKorea Co., Ltd.
301 Samdo Building, 12-1
Yeoido-dong, Yeongdeungpo-gu
Seoul, Korea 150-010
Tel: +82-2-578-3220
Fax: +82-2-578-3224


This month Business Korea is sponsored by: